Gov. Cox announces appointments to Utah Supreme Court and Third Judicial District Court

PRESS RELEASE

SALT LAKE CITY (Aug. 28, 2026) — Gov. Spencer J. Cox today announced the appointments of Judge Matthew L. Bell and Michael R. Menssen to serve on the Utah Supreme Court, and Elizabeth “Liz” Butler to serve on the Third Judicial District Court.

The Supreme Court appointments fill vacancies created by the retirement of Chief Justice Matthew Durrant and the resignation of Justice Diana Hagen.

Judge Bell serves as a district court judge in the Fifth Judicial District, a position he has held since 2017. He currently serves as the District’s presiding judge. His career in public service includes nine years as an assistant United States attorney for the District of Utah, service as a trial attorney for the U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division, and prior work as a sworn peace officer. Judge Bell earned his Juris Doctor magna cum laude from the J. Reuben Clark Law School at Brigham Young University, where he served as lead note and comment editor for the BYU Law Review.

“Over his decade of service on the Fifth District bench, Judge Matthew Bell has distinguished himself as one of our state’s finest judges,” Gov. Cox said. “He routinely receives top evaluation scores from attorneys, staff, and jurors alike. Having risen through Utah’s justice system from literal boots-on-the-ground law enforcement to federal prosecution and district court service, Judge Bell brings unparalleled practical wisdom, broad case experience, and a vital southern Utah perspective to our state’s highest court.”

The governor selected Judge Bell following an extensive review process conducted by the Appellate Court Nominating Commission.

“I am humbled and honored by the trust Governor Cox, his staff, and the Appellate Court Nominating Commission have placed in me,” Judge Bell said. “I understand the profound responsibility this appointment carries. If confirmed, I will remain steadfast in my sworn duty to support, obey, and defend the Constitution.”

RELATED: Utah Senate Confirms Jay Jorgensen and Stephen Dent to the Utah Supreme Court

The governor selected Menssen following the same review process.

“Michael Menssen brings an exceptional legal mind, top-quality experience, and a career-long dedication to textualism and originalism to the bench,” Gov. Cox said. “In addition to his success in complex commercial litigation, Michael has generously given his time to pro bono work for vulnerable Utahns. What impressed me most is his genuine humility and desire to serve—he is seeking this seat for all the right reasons.”

Menssen currently serves as a partner at Mayer Brown LLP in Salt Lake City, specializing in complex commercial litigation, labor and employment law, and appeals. He previously practiced as a partner at Stoel Rives LLP and as an associate at Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP. Menssen earned his Juris Doctor from the University of Virginia School of Law, where he served as Articles Editor for the Virginia Law Review and was inducted into the Order of the Coif.

Menssen has held leadership roles with local legal aid nonprofits and has been recognized for his pro bono work. He currently serves on the Board of Directors for the Legal Aid Society of Salt Lake, which assists low-income families and individuals and victims of domestic violence. He also chairs the Leadership Committee for And Justice for All, whose mission is to improve access to justice for all Utahns.

“I am humbled and honored by this nomination,” Menssen said. “I have a deep love and respect for the Constitution, the rule of law, and the role of an independent judiciary. If confirmed, I will always strive to be a faithful steward of the trust placed in me.”

To fill a vacancy on the Third Judicial District Court created by the retirement of Judge Hruby-Mills, Gov. Cox selected attorney Liz Butler following a nominating process conducted by the Third Judicial District Nominating Commission.

“Liz Butler is a dedicated practitioner and leader within Utah’s legal community,” Gov. Cox said. “Her impressive background in complex civil litigation, coupled with her service as an educator and community leader, makes her an outstanding addition to the district court bench.”

RELATED: Nominees announced for Third District Court vacancy

Butler currently serves as shareholder and co-chair of the Litigation Department at Parsons Behle & Latimer, overseeing more than 100 attorneys across the Mountain West. She previously served as shareholder and chair of the board at Jones Waldo Holbrook & McDonough. Butler also serves as an adjunct professor of law at the University of Utah S.J. Quinney College of Law. She earned her Juris Doctor with highest honors from the University of Utah S.J. Quinney College of Law, where she served on the Utah Law Review and graduated fifth in her class. Butler also volunteers with Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Search and Rescue.

“It is a tremendous honor to be appointed to serve on the Third Judicial District Court,” Butler said. “I am humbled and grateful to Governor Cox for the trust he’s placed in me and for the opportunity to serve the people of Utah. If confirmed, I will work hard to faithfully uphold the law and to ensure that all who appear before me are treated with dignity, fairness, and respect.”

Under the Utah Constitution, judicial appointments are subject to the advice and consent of the Utah Senate. The Senate Judicial Confirmation Committee will review each appointee’s record, consider public comments, and hold confirmation hearings prior to consideration by the full Senate.

Robert Carroll
Senior Advisor to Governor Cox
801-243-2290 | rcarroll@utah.gov

Gov. Cox appoints Lance Talakai to Third District Juvenile Court

PRESS RELEASE

SALT LAKE CITY (Aug. 11, 2026) — Gov. Spencer J. Cox has appointed Lance Talakai to serve as a judge in the Third District Juvenile Court, filling the vacancy created by the retirement of Judge David Johnson.

“Lance has spent his career serving people at some of the most consequential moments of their lives,” Gov. Cox said. “His extensive courtroom experience, including his work with serious youth offender cases, will serve Utah families well. I’m grateful for his willingness to take on this important responsibility.”

Talakai has worked as a defense attorney with the Salt Lake Legal Defender Association since 2012. During his 14 years with the association, he has represented clients in felony, misdemeanor and serious youth offender cases. He has also served in leadership roles, including as a felony team lead and co-misdemeanor chief, and has recruited, trained and supervised new attorneys.

“I am deeply humbled and honored to be appointed to serve as a juvenile court judge in the Third District,” Talakai said. “Having grown up in this district, I am especially grateful for the opportunity to serve the youth and families in the community that has been such an important part of my life.

“If confirmed, I will approach this responsibility with compassion, fairness and integrity. I am committed to serving with humility and ensuring that every young person and family who comes before the court is treated with dignity, respect and fairness.”

Before joining the Salt Lake Legal Defender Association, Talakai served as a law clerk for the Fourth District Court and worked with the Utah County Public Defender. He earned his law degree from Brigham Young University’s J. Reuben Clark Law School and a bachelor’s degree in sociology from the University of Hawaii at Manoa.

Talakai’s appointment is subject to confirmation by the Utah Senate.

Contact:
Rob Carroll
Office of the Governor
(801) 243-2290, rcarroll@utah.gov 

Day 2 Summary: Leadership, the Judiciary, and the Enduring Strength of the Rule of Law

The final full day of the Utah State Bar’s 95th Anniversary Summer Convention reflected on the profession’s past while looking confidently toward its future. Attorneys, judges, and legal professionals gathered for reports from Bar and judicial leaders, the swearing-in of new officers and commissioners, recognition of distinguished award recipients, candid conversations with the judiciary, and an inspiring keynote address from former U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson. The day concluded with practical CLE breakout sessions, bringing three days (August 6-8, 2026) of education and fellowship to a memorable close.

RELATED: Day 1 Summary: Inspiring Tone for the Bar’s 95th Anniversary Summer Convention

A Year of Progress

The morning opened with a final report from outgoing Utah State Bar President Kim Cordova, who reflected on the accomplishments of the past year with gratitude and humility. She credited the success of her presidency to the collaborative leadership of the Board of Bar Commissioners and the dedication of the Bar’s professional staff, thanking them for their tireless efforts in advancing the Bar’s mission and serving Utah’s legal community.

CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE SUN VALLEY PHOTO GALLERY

Reports from the State and Federal Judiciary

Chief Judge Jill Parrish provided attendees with an overview of the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah, highlighting both the strength of the federal judiciary and the demands placed upon it.

She reported that the District is currently served by six senior judges in the makeup of:

  • 11 U.S. District Judges
  • 5 U.S. Magistrate Judges
  • 3 U.S. Bankruptcy Judges

Judge Parrish also shared statistics illustrating the court’s significant workload, including civil, criminal, and minor cases (speeding in National Parks), while noting that the court conducts an average of 14 jury trials each year. Her remarks underscored the dedication of Utah’s federal judiciary in efficiently administering justice despite the demands.

Justice Paige Petersen followed with an update on the Utah Supreme Court during what has been one of the most significant periods of transition in recent history.

She discussed the Legislature’s expansion of the Supreme Court from five to seven justices and explained that, while the Court has been operating during the transition, the two newly created seats will officially be filled on August 31. Justice Petersen offered heartfelt gratitude to the federal and district court judges who stepped in on a few cases during this transition, recognizing their willingness to serve whenever called upon.

She also welcomed the Court’s newest members:

  • Justice John Nielsen
  • Justice Jay Jorgensen
  • Justice Stephen Dent

Justice Petersen paid tribute to former Justices John Pearce and Diana Hagen, thanking them for their years of distinguished service and lasting contributions to Utah’s judiciary.

The morning’s emotion continued as Justice Petersen accepted the Bar’s Lifetime Service Award on behalf of Chief Justice Matthew B. Durrant. Her remarks honoring his decades of visionary leadership, unwavering commitment to access to justice, and transformative impact on Utah’s courts culminated in a standing ovation from the audience.

Honoring Judge of the Year

Among the convention’s distinguished honorees was Hon. James D. Gardner, who received the Bar’s 2026 Judge of the Year Award in recognition of his exemplary judicial service and steadfast commitment to Utah’s legal community. Since joining the Third District Court in 2014, Judge Gardner has earned widespread respect for his fairness, professionalism, and thoughtful approach from the bench. Beyond the courtroom, he has devoted countless hours to advancing the profession through his service on the Utah Judicial Council, the Utah State Bar CLE Advisory Committee, and numerous initiatives focused on judicial excellence and professionalism.

Throughout the convention, Judge Gardner’s commitment to mentoring lawyers and strengthening advocacy was also evident as he shared his experience during CLE programming, exemplifying the collaborative spirit and dedication to public service that define this year’s award recipients.

Welcoming a New Generation of Bar Leadership

Justice Petersen also administered the oaths of office to the Bar’s incoming officers and newly elected Commissioners.

The Bar welcomed:

  • Tyler Young, President
  • Tom Bayles, President-Elect
  • Nicole Johnston, Young Lawyers Division President
  • Yvette Donosso, Commissioner
  • Jeremy Reutzel, Commissioner
  • Christian Hansen, Commissioner
  • Ezzy Khaosanga, Commissioner
  • Ashley Biehl, Commissioner

The Bar also expressed its sincere appreciation to outgoing Young Lawyers Division President Alex Vandiver for her dedicated leadership and service.

Following the swearing-in ceremony, newly installed President Tyler Young delivered heartfelt remarks that centered on the people who make the legal profession meaningful. Rather than seeing “the legal system,” he said, he sees the faces of mentors, colleagues, friends, and family members whose examples define the profession for him. He thanked several individuals by name for the influence they have had throughout his career and paid special tribute to his father for modeling integrity, service, and leadership, as well as expressing gratitude for the unwavering support of his family.

Young concluded with a thoughtful challenge to everyone in attendance. At 10 p.m., he encouraged each person to spend time sitting quietly in reflection, then rise early enough to watch the sunrise the following morning. Taking time to consider who we are, why we do this work, and what our purpose is, he said, is an experience that can profoundly shape both our personal lives and our professional calling.

Honoring Excellence

The convention also celebrated members of Utah’s legal community whose careers exemplify service, professionalism, and leadership.

This year’s recipients included:

  • Lifetime Service Award: Chief Justice Matthew B. Durrant
  • Lawyer of the Year: R. John Moody
  • Judge of the Year: Hon. James D. Gardner
  • Special Service Award: D. Gilbert (Gil) Athay
  • Committee of the Year: Governmental Relations Committee
  • Section of the Year: Utah State Bar Paralegal Division

Together, these honorees represent the dedication that continues to strengthen Utah’s legal profession and the administration of justice.

A Conversation with the Courts

The judicial panel, A Conversation with Our Courts, provided attendees with an honest discussion about the evolving challenges facing Utah’s state and federal courts. Panelists spoke candidly about judicial transitions, the construction of the new U.S. District Courthouse in St. George, increasing caseloads, limited staffing resources, and the continued commitment to delivering fair and accessible justice throughout the state.

The openness of the judges offered attendees valuable insight into the realities of today’s judiciary and reinforced the importance of collaboration between Utah’s bench and bar.

Jeh Johnson’s Call to Protect Democracy

Former U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson delivered an inspiring keynote address drawn from his work as co-chair of the American Bar Association Task Force on American Democracy.

Johnson emphasized that preserving constitutional democracy requires active engagement from the legal profession. He highlighted recommendations to strengthen civics education, safeguard elections and election workers, improve voting access while maintaining election security, combat political disinformation and AI-generated deception, reinforce lawyers’ ethical obligations, strengthen legal education, and promote respectful civil discourse.

His message reminded attendees that lawyers serve not only their clients but also the Constitution and the rule of law. The audience responded with a standing ovation in appreciation of his thoughtful and timely remarks.

Closing with Practical Learning

The afternoon concluded with the convention’s final series of CLE breakout sessions, offering attendees opportunities to deepen their knowledge across a wide range of practice areas.

Topics included:

  • Becoming Better Advocates, featuring judges and experienced litigators sharing practical advocacy skills.
  • A Young Lawyers Division program on mentoring, lawyering skills, and attorney well-being.
  • What’s the Deal With Securities?, using Seinfeld as a creative framework for understanding securities law.
  • AI’s Evolution & the Future of Foreseeability, exploring how artificial intelligence is reshaping legal duties and liability.
  • Giving Context to the Colorado River Conundrum, examining the legal history and future challenges surrounding western water law.

These sessions brought three outstanding days of continuing legal education to a fitting conclusion, equipping attorneys with practical knowledge while reinforcing the profession’s shared commitment to excellence.

Looking Ahead

As the Utah State Bar approaches its centennial in 2031, the final Summer Convention in Sun Valley served as both a celebration of the organization’s remarkable legacy and an affirmation of its future. Through thoughtful leadership, honest dialogue, recognition of extraordinary service, and a renewed commitment to the rule of law, the convention demonstrated that while future summer gatherings may take place elsewhere, the values that have guided the Bar for nearly 95 years—service, professionalism, integrity, and dedication to justice—remain as strong as ever.

*AI was used to write this summary of events.

Utah State Bar Celebrates 95 Years of Service, Honors Outstanding Legal Leaders at Sun Valley Summer Convention

PRESS RELEASE

SUN VALLEY, Idaho (August 7, 2026) — Against the backdrop of its 95th Anniversary Summer Convention, the Utah State Bar celebrated nearly a century of service to Utah’s legal profession by recognizing exceptional lawyers, judges, volunteers and leaders whose dedication has strengthened the justice system and the communities it serves.

This year’s convention also marked the conclusion of a cherished tradition. After decades of gathering in Sun Valley, 230 legal professionals came together one final time in the mountain setting that has hosted generations of attorneys, judges, and families while fostering professional excellence, collegiality and lifelong friendships.

“As we celebrate 95 years of the Utah State Bar, we also honor the people whose service has shaped our profession and improved access to justice for Utahns,” said Bar President Kim Cordova. “This year’s award recipients exemplify the highest ideals of professionalism, integrity, leadership and public service. Recognizing them during our final summer convention in Sun Valley makes this celebration especially meaningful as we reflect on our history and look toward the Bar’s future.”

CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE SUN VALLEY PHOTO GALLERY

The Bar presented the following distinguished awards:

Lifetime Service Award

Chief Justice Matthew B. Durrant
Chief Durrant received the Bar’s Lifetime Service Award in recognition of his extraordinary contributions to Utah’s judiciary and legal profession. During more than two decades on the Utah Supreme Court, including 14 years as Chief Justice, he has led nationally recognized efforts to modernize the courts, improve access to justice, expand court technology and strengthen public trust in the judicial system.

Lawyer of the Year

R. John Moody
Moody was honored as the 2026 Lawyer of the Year for a career dedicated to protecting Utah’s most vulnerable children. One of the original attorneys with Utah’s Office of Guardian ad Litem, Moody has spent more than three decades advocating for children and families while serving as a nationally certified Child Welfare Law Specialist. His collaborative leadership and commitment to improving Utah’s child welfare system have left a lasting impact on countless lives.

Judge of the Year

Hon. James D. Gardner
Judge Gardner, of Utah’s Third District Court, received the Judge of the Year Award for his distinguished judicial service and leadership. Since his appointment in 2014, Judge Gardner has served on the Utah Judicial Council, the Utah State Bar CLE Advisory Committee, and numerous committees dedicated to advancing professionalism and the administration of justice.

Special Service Award

D. Gilbert (Gil) Athay
Athay was presented with the Special Service Award for more than five decades of distinguished service to Utah’s legal profession. A respected criminal defense attorney and longtime chairman of the Salt Lake Legal Defender Association, Athay has built a career defined by vigorous advocacy, professional excellence and an unwavering commitment to the fair administration of justice.

Committee of the Year

Governmental Relations Committee
The Governmental Relations Committee was recognized as the 2026 Committee of the Year for its exceptional work during Utah’s 66th legislative session. Under the leadership of Co-Chairs Jaqualin Friend Peterson and Sara Bouley, committee members provided timely analysis, policy recommendations and advocacy on legislation affecting the legal profession, the courts and the public. Their collaborative efforts helped inform policymakers while protecting the integrity of Utah’s justice system.

Section of the Year

Utah State Bar Paralegal Division
The Bar’s Paralegal Division was named Section of the Year in recognition of its outstanding leadership, professional development programs, mentorship opportunities, and commitment to serving members throughout Utah. The 30-year-old division continues to elevate the paralegal profession while strengthening collaboration across the legal community.

As the Bar approaches its centennial in 2031, this year’s convention served as both a celebration of the organization’s rich history and a reminder that the strength of the legal profession depends on the dedication of individuals committed to serving others.

While the location of future summer conventions will evolve, the values that have defined the Bar for nearly 95 years—service, professionalism, integrity and the rule of law—remain steadfast. The achievements of this year’s award recipients embody those enduring principles and inspire the next generation of Utah legal professionals.

About the Utah State Bar
Established in 1931 and operating under the authority of the Utah Supreme Court, the Utah State Bar regulates and supports the legal profession in the state. With over 12,000 licensed attorneys, the Bar is committed to promoting a justice system that is accessible, understood, valued, and respected. Governed by a Commission of elected attorneys from Utah’s judicial districts, the Bar provides resources, education, and support to enhance the professional practice of its licensees and upholds the public’s trust in the legal system.

###

Day 1 Summary: Inspiring Tone for the Bar’s 95th Anniversary Summer Convention

The Utah State Bar’s 95th Anniversary Summer Convention is off to an exceptional start in beautiful Sun Valley, Idaho, bringing together more than 250 attorneys. The convention officially began Wednesday evening with a vibrant opening reception of nearly 600 people on the Sun Valley Lodge Terrace, where colleagues and friends reunited over a catered dinner while families enjoyed ice skating beneath the mountain sky. The reception, sponsored by Ray Quinney & Nebeker, welcomed all convention attendees, faculty and guests, setting the tone for Thursday’s educational presentations, networking and camaraderie.

RELATED: Utah State Bar Concludes Historic 95th Anniversary Celebration at Sun Valley Summer Convention

As the convention continues, the Bar extends sincere appreciation to Sun Valley Convention Co-Chairs Chief Magistrate Cecilia M. Romero and Christina M. Jeppson, whose leadership helped bring this milestone event together. Special thanks also go to the Bar’s generous sponsors, led by Presenting Sponsor Parsons Behle & Latimer, whose support makes the convention possible, and to the many exhibitors who provide valuable resources and services to Utah’s legal community.

CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE SUN VALLEY PHOTO GALLERY

Justice Gregory Moeller Opens Convention with Powerful Lessons on Integrity

Thursday’s CLE program began with a compelling keynote from Justice Gregory Moeller of the Idaho Supreme Court, whose remarks blended personal reflection with hard-earned lessons from decades in the courtroom. Justice Moeller shared that his inspiration to pursue a legal career traces back to his high school years in South Fremont, Idaho, when he watched the film adaptation of To Kill a Mockingbird.

The story of Tom Robinson—a Black man falsely accused of raping a white woman—and, in particular, the unforgettable courtroom moment when Reverend Sykes quietly tells Scout, “Stand up. Your father’s passin’,” left a lasting impression on the future justice. For Moeller, Atticus Finch embodied the courage and moral integrity every lawyer should aspire to, even when facing overwhelming public opposition.

That theme carried into one of the defining cases of his career.

Just eight months after passing the bar exam, Moeller was appointed to represent Rauland Grube, who had been charged with murdering a woman nearly eight years earlier. Despite intense public scrutiny, Moeller remained convinced of his client’s innocence and described Grube as someone he believed was “incapable of violence.”

For 16 years, Moeller pursued justice on Grube’s behalf through relentless litigation. Throughout the case, media attention remained intense, community emotions ran high, and threats were directed not only at Grube but also at Moeller and his family.

Eventually, the charges were dismissed, and Grube’s constitutional rights were fully restored. Tragically, he died only a few years after regaining his freedom.

Looking back, Moeller reflected that the case “haunted me almost every day it lasted,” reminding attendees that practicing law often demands resilience, courage and an unwavering commitment to justice, even under extraordinary pressure.

Inside One of America’s Most Watched Criminal Cases

The morning continued with Lindsey Blake, lead prosecutor in the nationally known Lori Vallow Daybell murder case.

Blake walked attendees through the extraordinary investigation that captivated audiences across the country because of its so-called “doomsday” beliefs and complex web of crimes. Using a detailed timeline, she demonstrated how investigators gradually assembled the case through extensive cooperation among multiple Idaho counties and law enforcement agencies across several states.

Her presentation offered attendees a rare behind-the-scenes perspective on managing a large-scale prosecution involving thousands of investigative leads, interagency collaboration and intense national media attention.

AI’s Impact Compared to the Arrival of Electricity

Following an exhibitor showcase, Bennett Borden, the first Chief Data Scientist at an Am Law firm and founder of Clarion AI, challenged attorneys to think differently about artificial intelligence and the future of legal practice.

Borden traced the evolution of technology throughout his career before making a striking comparison: artificial intelligence, he said, is transforming society much like electricity once did.

Rather than viewing AI as simply another legal tool, Borden encouraged lawyers to recognize it as a foundational technology reshaping nearly every aspect of business and daily life. His presentation focused on how attorneys should advise clients about the responsible use of AI while also embracing its growing role within their own practices.

Afternoon Breakout Sessions Offer Specialized Learning

In the afternoon, attendees had the opportunity to tailor their continuing legal education experience through five concurrent breakout sessions covering some of today’s most relevant legal topics.

Participants may choose from:

  • Immigration Law with Magistrate Judge Dustin Pead.
  • AI: Practical & Interactive CLE, where Bennett Borden offers hands-on strategies for integrating artificial intelligence into legal practice.
  • Recent Appellate and U.S. Supreme Court Decisions, presented by Michelle Quist.
  • Bankruptcy Panel Discussion featuring Engels Tejeda and Ellen Ostrow.
  • Becoming Better Negotiators, presented by the Litigation Section and Young Lawyers Division, focusing on practical negotiation skills for attorneys at every stage of practice.

Law School Reunions Celebrate Lifelong Connections

The day concludes with one of the convention’s most anticipated traditions—law school receptions and networking events. Alumni from the S.J. Quinney College of Law will gather on the Limelight Terrace, while graduates of the BYU J. Reuben Clark Law School will reunite on the Duck Pond Lawn. These receptions provide an opportunity for classmates, mentors and colleagues to reconnect while welcoming the next generation of Utah attorneys into the profession’s enduring community.

As the Utah State Bar celebrates its 95th anniversary, the first full day of programming has demonstrated the enduring strength of the profession—bringing together thoughtful discussions on justice, groundbreaking technology, professional development and the friendships that have long defined the Summer Convention.

RELATED: Day 2 Summary: Leadership, the Judiciary, and the Enduring Strength of the Rule of Law

With outstanding educational programming, generous sponsors and exhibitors, and the stunning backdrop of Sun Valley, the convention continues to honor the Bar’s rich history while preparing attorneys for the future of legal practice.

*AI was used to write this summary of events.

Nominees announced for two Utah Supreme Court vacancies

PRESS RELEASE

SALT LAKE CITY (Aug. 6, 2026) — The Appellate Judicial Nominating Commission has selected nominees for two vacancies on the Utah Supreme Court. These vacancies result from the retirement of Justice Diana Hagen, on May 8, 2026 and Chief Justice Matthew Durrant, on Aug. 31, 2026.

The nominees for the vacancies are:

  • Cherise Bacalski, founder and appellate attorney, The Appellate Group, and adjunct professor of writing, J. Reuben Clark Law School at Brigham Young University;
  • Christopher Ballard, general counsel and chief of staff, Utah County Attorney’s Office;
  • Christopher Bates, shareholder, Kirton McConkie;
  • Matthew Bates, judge, Third District Court;
  • Matthew Bell, judge, Fifth District Court;
  • Samuel Chiara, judge, Eighth District Court;
  • Michele Christiansen Forster, judge, Utah Court of Appeals;
  • William Hains, deputy division director, Criminal Appeals, Office of the Attorney General;
  • Michael Menssen, partner, Mayer Brown LLP;
  • Amy Oliver, judge, Utah Court of Appeals;
  • Stanford Purser, solicitor general, Office of the Utah Attorney General; and
  • Ryan Tenney, judge, Utah Court of Appeals.

Written comments can be submitted to the Appellate Judicial Nominating Commission at judicialvacancies@utah.gov or Commission on Criminal and Juvenile Justice, P.O. Box 142330, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-2330.  The deadline for written comments is noon Aug. 16, 2026. The Nominating Commission may request further information or conduct an investigation of the nominees after reviewing public comments.  After the public comment period, the names will be sent to Gov. Spencer J. Cox, who will have 30 days to make the appointment for each vacancy. Gov. Cox’s appointees are subject to confirmation by the Utah Senate.

###

Robert Carroll
Senior Advisor to Governor Cox
801-243-2290 | rcarroll@utah.gov

Utah State Bar Concludes Historic 95th Anniversary Celebration at Sun Valley Summer Convention

PRESS RELEASE

SUN VALLEY, Idaho (August 5, 2026) — The Utah State Bar will conclude its year-long 95th Anniversary celebration during its Summer Convention, Aug. 6-7, in Sun Valley, Idaho, marking both nearly a century of service to Utah’s legal profession and the final time the Bar will host its signature summer gathering in the iconic mountain resort community. The anniversary campaign centered on the theme, “Honoring Our Legacy, Building Our Future,” and celebrated the Bar’s history while reaffirming its commitment to the future of the legal profession.

For more than four decades, beginning in the 1980s, generations of Utah attorneys, judges, legal professionals and their families have gathered in Sun Valley for continuing legal education, professional networking and lifelong friendships. The 2026 convention serves as both a celebration of that enduring tradition and a meaningful transition as the Bar looks ahead to its next chapter.

“This convention is much more than the conclusion of a 95th anniversary celebration,” said Utah State Bar President Kim Cordova. “It is an opportunity to reflect on nearly a century of service to Utah, honor the people and milestones that brought us here, and reaffirm our responsibility to protect the rule of law and ensure a judicial system that remains fair, independent and accessible for generations to come.”

Throughout the past year, the Bar commemorated its milestone anniversary through educational programming, historical storytelling and public engagement that highlighted the evolution of Utah’s legal profession and the enduring principles that guide it.

Highlights of the anniversary celebration included:

  • A dedicated 95th Anniversary webpage chronicling the Bar’s history, oral histories and significant milestones.
  • Weekly social media features highlighting pivotal moments in Utah legal history and the evolution of the legal profession.
  • A professionally produced video honoring the Attorney’s Oath and its enduring importance to the practice of law.
  • A successful anniversary continuing legal education (CLE) series examining historic legal developments and contemporary issues facing the profession.
  • The Let’s Talk, Let’s Listen civic dialogue series, which brought together Utah’s legislative and judicial leaders for respectful conversations about the constitutional roles of government and the importance of public understanding of the judiciary. The series included conversations featuring Senate President J. Stuart Adams, Speaker of the House Mike Schultz, members of Utah’s appellate courts and judicial leadership.
  • The landmark America250: Sharing Stories About America constitutional symposium, featuring nationally recognized constitutional scholars Jeffrey Rosen and Professor Jonathan Turley alongside distinguished members of Utah’s judiciary and civic leadership. The symposium connected the Bar’s 95-year legacy with the nation’s upcoming 250th anniversary, emphasizing the enduring importance of constitutional governance and the rule of law.
  • A rare and candid “Conversation with Our Courts” discussion, providing attendees with unique insights from members of Utah’s state and federal judiciary about the administration of justice, judicial independence and recent developments affecting Utah’s courts.

The anniversary also recognized excellence within the Bar’s own staff.

During the commemorative year, Michelle Oldroyd, the Bar’s CLE Officer, received the Spirit of Quinney Award from the S.J. Quinney College of Law in recognition of her longstanding contributions to legal education and the legal profession. Executive Director Elizabeth Wright was honored by Women Lawyers of Utah as Mentor of the Year, recognizing her decades of leadership, mentorship and dedication to advancing the legal community.

The Summer Convention itself reflects the anniversary’s focus on honoring the past while preparing for the future. Nationally recognized speakers include former U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson, Idaho Supreme Court Justice Gregory Moeller, and prosecutor Lindsay Blake, along with programming devoted to artificial intelligence, immigration, western water law, professionalism, civility and the evolving practice of law.

The convention will also feature the presentation of the Utah State Bar’s annual awards, recognizing outstanding lawyers, judges, volunteers and legal professionals whose service exemplifies the profession’s highest ideals.

While the Bar bids farewell to one of its most cherished traditions, its mission remains unchanged.

“For 95 years, the Utah State Bar has served as a steward of the legal profession and a trusted partner in advancing justice,” said Bar Executive Director Elizabeth Wright. “As we close this chapter in Sun Valley and begin preparing for our centennial, we remain steadfast in our commitment to the rule of law, judicial independence, professionalism, and a justice system dedicated to fairness, equality and public trust.”

As the Bar approaches its 100th anniversary in 2031, it will continue building on the legacy established since its founding in 1931—strengthening the legal profession, supporting its licensees, expanding access to justice and serving the people of Utah with integrity and excellence.

About the Utah State Bar
Established in 1931 and operating under the authority of the Utah Supreme Court, the Utah State Bar regulates and supports the legal profession in the state. With over 12,000 licensed attorneys, the Bar is committed to promoting a justice system that is accessible, understood, valued, and respected. Governed by a Commission of elected attorneys from Utah’s judicial districts, the Bar provides resources, education, and support to enhance the professional practice of its licensees and upholds the public’s trust in the legal system.

###

How to Select a Backup and Successor Attorney and Why Doing So Matters

By Mark Bassingthwaighte, Esq.

Solo attorneys face unique operational and ethical risks when unexpected absences occur. Illness, emergencies, or other disruptions can jeopardize client interests if no continuity plan is in place. Designating a backup or successor attorney is one of the most effective ways to reduce malpractice exposure and ensure uninterrupted client service.

Understanding the Difference Between a Backup Attorney and a Successor Attorney

For most solos, the same individual often agrees to serve as both a backup and successor attorney. While the roles are related, they serve distinct purposes:

  • Backup Attorney – Provides short‑term coverage during temporary absences such as vacations, brief illnesses, or emergencies.
  • Successor Attorney – Steps in to wind down the practice in the event of the solo practitioner’s death, disability, or incapacity.

Neither role involves running a second practice long‑term. Clarifying this distinction can make it easier to find a colleague willing to serve, especially if there’s a decision to make the arrangement reciprocal.

Key Qualities to Look for When Selecting a Backup/Successor Attorney

Choosing the right individual is essential for protecting clients and minimizing risk. Look for someone who:

  • Is competent and experienced in your primary practice areas,
  • Is unlikely to encounter significant conflicts of interest,
  • Has the time, or the ability to find the time, to take on additional responsibilities for short‑periods of time, and
  • Understands the ethical obligations involved in stepping into your practice.

Once selected, make sure to let your staff know who this person is and how he or she can be reached in the event of an emergency.

Essential Preparatory Steps

Beyond designating a backup/successor attorney, there are several other things you should do as part of the process.

  • Prioritize maintaining a current office procedures manual that discusses the calendaring system, conflict system, active file list, open and closed file systems, accounting system, and any other key system. This can be valuable in expeditiously bringing the designated attorney up to speed on how your practice is run.
  • Keep critical systems such as the calendar and conflict systems current at all times.
  • And make certain that all files are thoroughly documented and current as to their status because the designated attorney will need to make decisions based upon what’s in your files. Mistakes can and will be made with poorly documented and/or incomplete files.

Reducing Malpractice Risk Through Proactive Client Communication

Finally, proactively informing clients about your backup/successor attorney arrangement reinforces transparency and demonstrates your commitment to protecting their interests. Including a brief notice in your fee agreement is a simple, effective way to set expectations and reduce confusion during an emergency. Consider using something along the lines of the following:

Succession Planning / Backup Attorney Notice:

While I strive to deliver excellent legal services to every client, I also have an ethical obligation to protect your interests during any extended absences, such as a vacation, an illness, or in the event of my unexpected death or disability. To accomplish this, I have named [insert name] as my backup attorney. This attorney will be available during any extended absences or may step in to assist in the closing of my practice should that ever prove necessary. I will provide advance notice of any planned absences, and my office staff or backup attorney will contact you with information on how to proceed should any unexpected event occur.

Mark Bassingthwaighte, Esq. Is the resident Risk Manager at ALPS Insurance. To learn more about how ALPS can support your solo or small firm visit: alpsinsurance.com

Nominees announced for Third District Court vacancy

SALT LAKE CITY (July 23, 2026) — The Third District Judicial Nominating Commission has selected nominees for a vacancy on the Third District Court. The vacancy results from the retirement of Judge Elizabeth Hruby-Mills, effective Dec. 1, 2026.

The nominees for the vacancy are:

  • Todd Bouton, assistant United States attorney, United States Attorney’s Office;
  • Elizabeth Butler, shareholder and co-chair of the litigation department, Parsons Behle & Latimer;
  • Matthew Janzen, Special Victims Unit division chief and deputy county attorney, Davis County Attorney’s Office;
  • Meagan Rudd, partner and attorney, The Rudd Firm P.C., doing business as Rudd Cooper; and
  • Lance Talakai, team leader, Salt Lake Legal Defender Association.

Written comments may be submitted to the Third District Judicial Nominating Commission at judicialvacancies@utah.gov or to the Commission on Criminal and Juvenile Justice, P.O. Box 142330, Salt Lake City, UT 84114-2330. The deadline for comments is noon Aug. 3, 2026.

The commission may request additional information or investigate the nominees after reviewing public comments. Following the public comment period, the nominees’ names will be submitted to Gov. Spencer J. Cox, who will have 30 days to make an appointment. The governor’s appointee is subject to confirmation by the Utah Senate.

###

CONTACT:
Robert Carroll
Senior Advisor to Governor Cox
801-243-2290 | rcarroll@utah.gov

Access to Justice Office on KUTV Fresh Living: Helping Utahns find the legal help they need

In a recent segment on KUTV’s Fresh Living, host Kari Hawker-Diaz welcomed Utah State Bar Access to Justice Director Megan Connelly to discuss a pressing issue facing many families across the state: navigating the civil justice system. Airing on June 10, 2026, the feature highlighted the vital resources provided by the state’s Access to Justice Office, shedding light on how everyday residents can find critical legal guidance when they need it most.

Navigating civil legal challenges like landlord-tenant disputes, custody battles, or debt collections can be overwhelming for many Utahns, particularly those who cannot afford traditional legal representation. This issue is compounded by stark geographical disparities across the state; while urban centers like Salt Lake County have stable attorney numbers, rural areas such as San Juan County operate as “legal deserts” with fewer than one attorney per 1,000 residents. According to the Utah Bar Foundation, the vast majority of defendants in debt collection and eviction cases are left to represent themselves against represented plaintiffs, underscoring a critical gap in the state’s civil justice system.

To bridge this gap, the Utah Access to Justice Office connects residents with trusted legal tools, self-help resources, and volunteer programs. A key initiative is their Virtual Legal Clinic, which offers eligible individuals free video or phone consultations with volunteer attorneys to clarify their rights and determine next steps before or during a court case. The office is also spearheading long-term solutions—including regulatory reforms and the upcoming Access to Justice Summit—to ensure affordable, widespread legal support for everyone in the state.

To learn more about how to access these services or support these initiatives, read the full article at utahlegalhelp.org.

Search UtahBar.org